Ethics · Original 40-mark-style practice

Reason can identify universal moral goods without relying on religious belief. Discuss.

Free essay plan for Natural Law: use scholar evidence, challenge the strongest arguments and reach a judgement on this exact question.

OCR RS Revision editorial team · Published · Editorial approach

Independent OCR H573 practice, not an official OCR question or a complete model essay. This is one defensible route; a different conclusion can work when supported by reasons.

A possible answer

Reason can identify shared goods such as preserving life, learning and cooperation without first accepting a revelation. Aquinas therefore gives non-believers a genuine role in moral reasoning, even though his explanation of natural law ultimately depends on God. The difficult step is moving from broad human interests to universally binding rules: agreement that life matters does not automatically settle conflicts about how life should be protected in particular circumstances.

Build your thesis

Distinguish knowing moral goods from explaining their ultimate authority. Religious belief is unnecessary for recognising many goods, but neither natural inclinations nor consensus alone establishes every universal moral rule claimed by natural law.

Three debates to develop

Debate 1

Separate access from foundation

Case and evidence. Use Aquinas's distinction between eternal law and human participation in it: rational creatures can recognise natural law through practical reasoning rather than needing every duty revealed in scripture. The goods of survival and social life offer accessible starting points.

Challenge. Aquinas still situates those goods within a created order directed towards ends; removing God might remove his explanation of why nature has moral authority.

Weigh it up. This challenges the theory's ultimate foundation, not the claim that non-believers can discover genuine moral goods. Keep those questions separate.

Debate 2

Test the move from nature to obligation

Case and evidence. Explain how primary precepts organise practical reasoning around human flourishing, then apply preservation of life to an ordinary obligation to rescue someone at little personal risk. Such reasoning can be shared across religious and secular outlooks.

Challenge. Humans also possess competing inclinations, and describing what is widespread does not by itself show what ought to be pursued. People disagree about whether biological functions determine morally required conduct.

Weigh it up. Defend the particular good with reasons about flourishing; simply labelling an action natural leaves the central moral inference unsupported.

Debate 3

Distinguish universal goods from fixed applications

Case and evidence. Aquinas allows variation and error in practical conclusions even where basic principles are shared. Use a conflict between protecting life and returning borrowed property to show why a general good does not operate as an exceptionless instruction for every case.

Challenge. If circumstances can alter the right application, critics may suspect that allegedly universal morality is only disguised situation ethics; proportionalist approaches make this pressure particularly clear.

Weigh it up. Contextual judgement need not erase the good itself, but universality becomes more credible at the level of principles than detailed prohibitions.

Reach a reasoned conclusion

A qualified agreement is strongest: shared rational reflection can identify moral goods independently of religious commitment. Aquinas's theological account supplies one explanation of their authority, while disagreements about nature and conflicting goods limit how confidently reason can derive detailed universal rules from them.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Do not equate natural law with divine command theory: Aquinas treats reason as a real route to moral knowledge, rather than merely repeating revealed instructions.
  • Do not infer that disagreement disproves every shared good; explain whether the disagreement concerns a basic principle, its interpretation or its application.

Sources to read for yourself

Use these primary texts to check the positions discussed above. The plan and evaluation are our independent teaching interpretation.

Turn the plan into your own essay

  1. Close the plan and write your answer to the question in one sentence.
  2. Choose the strongest objection to that answer and explain how it changes your judgement.
  3. Write a paragraph using a precise scholar or source, then check it against the 40-mark essay checklist.