A possible answer
Agape can give clearer guidance about the purpose of morality: people should be treated with selfless concern rather than sacrificed to a rule. It is less clearly superior when a decision requires an agreed procedure or a reliable prediction. Fletcher's approach is strongest where a rule produces an obvious injustice, but saying that love decides does not itself tell different decision-makers which available action will genuinely serve the people affected.
Build your thesis
Evaluate clarity at two levels: moral priority and practical decision. Agape provides a compelling priority, while stable rules often give more predictable guidance; the best defence of Fletcher must explain how responsible judgement avoids becoming self-justification.
Three debates to develop
Give persons priority over rules
Case and evidence. Explain Fletcher's personalism and the difference between agape and liking someone: moral concern extends even to an unpopular person. A rule against lying may conflict with protecting a persecuted neighbour, making the neighbour's welfare morally clearer than literal obedience.
Challenge. A defender of rules can agree that persons matter while arguing that rules already embody accumulated concern for them, especially against self-serving exceptions.
Weigh it up. Agape identifies the proper beneficiary of morality, but this alone does not show that every settled rule should be overridden.
Ask how love selects an action
Case and evidence. Use Fletcher's pragmatism and situational judgement to ask what will actually help those affected, rather than merely expressing kindly intentions. Consider whether breaking a promise protects someone from serious harm or only avoids an uncomfortable conversation.
Challenge. The future is uncertain, interests conflict and the decision-maker may favour friends while describing that preference as love. Two sincere people can reach incompatible conclusions from the same principle.
Weigh it up. Flexibility can improve responsiveness while reducing predictability; greater sensitivity is not automatically greater clarity about the action required.
Use rules as guidance, not absolutes
Case and evidence. Fletcher distinguishes situation ethics from both legalism and principle-free antinomianism; inherited rules can guide deliberation without having unconditional authority. Compare his position with Romans 13, where love and commandments are related rather than treated as obvious enemies.
Challenge. Once rules become useful presumptions, the dispute concerns their authority and exceptions rather than whether love or rules should exist at all.
Weigh it up. Defend exceptional departures through impartial reasons and evidence of consequences, showing why this case defeats the normal protection supplied by a rule.
Reach a reasoned conclusion
Agape is clearer as a criterion of moral purpose than as a complete decision procedure. The strongest judgement credits Fletcher for correcting inflexible legalism while requiring public reasons, careful factual assessment and attention to the protective role of rules before accepting a particular exception.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Do not define agape as romantic feeling, personal preference or whichever action creates the most pleasure; Fletcher's concern is impartial love of persons.
- Do not call situation ethics completely ruleless: the issue is whether ordinary rules have final authority when they conflict with agape in a particular case.
Sources to read for yourself
Use these primary texts to check the positions discussed above. The plan and evaluation are our independent teaching interpretation.
Turn the plan into your own essay
- Close the plan and write your answer to the question in one sentence.
- Choose the strongest objection to that answer and explain how it changes your judgement.
- Write a paragraph using a precise scholar or source, then check it against the 40-mark essay checklist.