A possible answer
Soul-making offers a reason why a good God might permit challenge, vulnerability and genuine consequences, but it is less successful at explaining suffering that destroys agency or produces no apparent growth. Hick's account is strongest as an explanation of a developmental world, rather than a demonstration that every tragedy benefits its victim. Adequacy therefore depends on the standard required: a possible reconciliation of God and suffering is weaker than a morally persuasive explanation of its actual extent and distribution.
Build your thesis
Soul-making gives a coherent purpose to some difficulty, but cannot by itself justify apparently pointless suffering; the strongest defence must explain excess and unequal outcomes while respecting sufferers as persons rather than instruments of others' development.
Three debates to develop
Explain why growth needs a challenging environment
Case and evidence. Hick develops the Irenaean tradition by presenting moral maturity as freely achieved; epistemic distance permits a response to God that is not overwhelmed by an unmistakable awareness of divine presence.
Challenge. Some challenge enables courage or compassion without making every severity necessary; moderate risk might allow development without the most destructive forms of illness, disaster or deprivation in this world.
Weigh it up. Grant a world-level explanation, then test the actual degree of harm; moving from growth requires difficulty to all actual suffering is justified would exceed what the argument has shown.
Test the cases where development appears impossible
Case and evidence. Destructive childhood illness, animal pain and disasters can remove opportunities for meaningful choice; such apparently gratuitous suffering sharpens Rowe's evidential challenge to a universally loving and powerful God.
Challenge. Humans cannot survey every consequence or divine reason, and helping can develop compassion; however, ignorance of a purpose does not constitute evidence that an adequate purpose actually exists.
Weigh it up. Apparent pointlessness does not prove actual pointlessness with certainty; repeated non-developmental suffering nevertheless weakens the account's probability, and using a victim for another's growth raises a separate moral objection.
Assess what an afterlife could repair
Case and evidence. Hick's eschatological completion addresses unfinished growth, suggesting divine purposes need not end within a short or damaged life; it extends the account beyond benefits that can be observed immediately.
Challenge. Future fulfilment cannot be independently inspected, and compensation does not automatically make an earlier injury necessary or permissible; the later good must concern the sufferer's own flourishing and agency.
Weigh it up. An afterlife strengthens coherence without settling every objection; distinguish overcoming suffering from showing that permitting this particular suffering was an acceptable way of producing the eventual good for its victim.
Reach a reasoned conclusion
Judge soul-making adequate as a partial account of why a purposeful world might contain vulnerability, but insufficient as a complete explanation of apparently pointless suffering. The decisive pressure is not the existence of any pain: it is destructive excess, unequal opportunity and the moral status of each sufferer.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Assuming Hick says every individual tragedy visibly improves the person who suffers, without considering unfinished growth or eschatology.
- Confusing an evidential challenge about apparently gratuitous suffering with a strict logical proof that God and all evil are incompatible.
Sources to read for yourself
Use these primary texts to check the positions discussed above. The plan and evaluation are our independent teaching interpretation.
Turn the plan into your own essay
- Close the plan and write your answer to the question in one sentence.
- Choose the strongest objection to that answer and explain how it changes your judgement.
- Write a paragraph using a precise scholar or source, then check it against the 40-mark essay checklist.