A possible answer
Non-cognitivism explains why moral disputes often involve conflicting attitudes and attempts to influence action, rather than simply correcting a factual mistake. However, disagreement alone does not establish that moral claims lack truth value: people also disagree about matters they regard as factual. The strongest assessment asks whether emotivism or prescriptivism can explain reasoned criticism and genuine changes of mind better than a cognitivist account of mistaken or incomplete moral judgement.
Build your thesis
Non-cognitivism captures the practical and emotional force of moral disagreement, but its explanatory advantage is limited unless it also explains why reasons can improve a judgement. Persistent disagreement is evidence to interpret, not a proof against moral truth.
Three debates to develop
Explain what emotivism captures
Case and evidence. Use Ayer's account to distinguish an ethical utterance expressing approval or disapproval from an empirical report that the speaker has a feeling. In a dispute about punishment, speakers may share the facts yet retain opposed attitudes towards suffering and desert.
Challenge. The intensity of that disagreement shows that values matter to the speakers, but does not logically establish that their statements cannot be true or false.
Weigh it up. Emotivism explains motivational force effectively; it still needs a further argument to establish its semantic claim about moral language.
Ask whether disagreement can be rational
Case and evidence. Test whether opponents change their moral judgements after discovering inconsistency, hidden bias or previously ignored interests. Hare's prescriptivism supplies a comparison because prescriptions claim a universal scope, making consistency more central than a simple expression of preference might suggest.
Challenge. People can remain logically consistent while endorsing harsh principles, so consistency alone does not demonstrate that one moral outlook is better than another.
Weigh it up. Distinguish constraints on reasoning from proof of a substantive moral conclusion; non-cognitivists need not claim that argument has no role.
Compare cognitivist explanations
Case and evidence. A moral realist can explain disagreement through incomplete knowledge, distorted reasoning or conflicting interpretations of a good, just as disagreement in other fields need not abolish truth. An intuitionist might defend moral knowledge while acknowledging that particular judgements can be mistaken.
Challenge. This response risks protecting realism from every possible objection unless it explains how competing judgements could actually be assessed and corrected.
Weigh it up. Compare explanatory costs on both sides: non-cognitivism must explain reasoned moral progress, while realism must explain access to disputed moral truths.
Reach a reasoned conclusion
Non-cognitivism provides a persuasive account of disagreement's attitudinal and action-guiding dimensions, especially when facts are shared. It is less clearly the best complete explanation of moral reasoning and correction. A qualified conclusion should identify what it explains well without treating disagreement itself as a demonstration that moral truth is impossible.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Do not confuse non-cognitivism with the claim that nobody can know an existing moral truth; it concerns what moral statements mean and whether they assert truth-evaluable propositions.
- Do not infer non-cognitivism directly from cultural variation: explain why the same evidence cannot also be explained by error, different circumstances or incomplete understanding.
Sources to read for yourself
Use these primary texts to check the positions discussed above. The plan and evaluation are our independent teaching interpretation.
Turn the plan into your own essay
- Close the plan and write your answer to the question in one sentence.
- Choose the strongest objection to that answer and explain how it changes your judgement.
- Write a paragraph using a precise scholar or source, then check it against the 40-mark essay checklist.