A possible answer
Original sin creates a serious difficulty for responsibility if blame requires an undamaged ability to choose otherwise. Augustine nevertheless distinguishes a will that acts voluntarily from a will that can heal itself: fallen people still desire and choose, although grace is needed for their restoration. A strong answer tests both claims. Explaining personal wrongdoing through corrupted desire is more convincing than explaining why anyone deserves blame for a condition inherited before personal choice.
Build your thesis
Augustine can preserve responsibility for voluntary actions without claiming that fallen humanity can save itself. His account remains vulnerable where inherited guilt and unequal dependence on grace appear to make moral desert independent of an individual's choices.
Three debates to develop
Distinguish voluntary action from spiritual self-sufficiency
Case and evidence. Explain Augustine's view that sin disorders love and desire rather than turning every human action into an externally forced event. Someone may act willingly from pride even when that person cannot independently restore a rightly ordered relationship with God.
Challenge. A critic can grant that the action expresses the person's desires while questioning whether those desires are sufficiently under the person's control to ground blame.
Weigh it up. Voluntariness answers the objection that humans are simply puppets. It does not yet establish that their inherited moral condition is fair.
Test responsibility for the inherited condition
Case and evidence. Set Augustine's solidarity with Adam against an individual account of responsibility. The Fall explains a shared human predicament, while concupiscence helps explain the persistence of self-interested conduct even when people recognise a better course.
Challenge. An explanatory account of widespread selfishness does not by itself justify holding a child responsible for another person's original disobedience. Biological or communal transmission and moral guilt are different claims.
Weigh it up. The inherited-guilt objection therefore attacks a deeper point than the observation that people sometimes find good actions difficult.
Ask what grace restores and whether it is just
Case and evidence. Use On the Spirit and the Letter to show why Augustine treats grace as enabling love and willing obedience, rather than merely supplying information. A divine command can identify the good without giving a damaged will the capacity to delight in it.
Challenge. If effective restoration depends on God's gift, an objection concerns those who do not receive it. Calling grace undeserved does not automatically answer whether condemnation is proportionate.
Weigh it up. Grace makes Augustine's theological solution coherent from within faith, but the fairness of unequal rescue needs a separate defence.
Reach a reasoned conclusion
Conclude that the word impossible is too strong: Augustine retains a meaningful distinction between willing sin and being compelled. Nevertheless, his defence is strongest for particular voluntary actions and weakest for inherited guilt. State which understanding of responsibility your conclusion uses, rather than switching definitions halfway through.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Do not equate original sin with the claim that every individual action is as evil as it could possibly be.
- Do not treat Pelagius as merely denying that people sin; the central dispute concerns ability, grace and the consequences of Adam's sin.
Sources to read for yourself
Use these primary texts to check the positions discussed above. The plan and evaluation are our independent teaching interpretation.
Turn the plan into your own essay
- Close the plan and write your answer to the question in one sentence.
- Choose the strongest objection to that answer and explain how it changes your judgement.
- Write a paragraph using a precise scholar or source, then check it against the 40-mark essay checklist.